A Simple Tweak Could Make Fecal Transplants Less Gross

Companies are trying to take the "ick" factor out of fecal transplants.

Aug 28 (Reuters) - The seventh time Catherine Duff contracted C. diff, a debilitating infection of the gut, she did not respond to antibiotics. She believes her life was saved by a transplant of her husband’s feces.

Several companies are now testing their own variations of fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) in a race to market a treatment for a stubborn bacterial infection that kills 29,000 Americans every year.

Cambridge, Massachusetts-based Seres Therapeutics Inc and Roseville, Minnesota-based Rebiotix Inc have begun late-stage trials of their respective treatments, with the latter company aiming to launch a product by the middle of 2019.

“It’s like getting a ’flu shot,” said Rebiotix Chief Executive Lee Jones, referring to her company’s enema therapy.

First documented centuries ago in China, the concept of replenishing a patient’s gut with bacteria from a healthy stool has been used in the United States only since the 1950s, with little regulation, according to the Fecal Transplant Foundation.

In 2013, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration sanctioned FMT as a last-resort therapy for recurrent strains of C. diff, or clostridium difficile infection - an infection common in U.S. hospitals that in some cases has grown resistant to antibiotics.

The FDA still considers FMT an “investigational treatment” pending further research into its safety and effectiveness.

Duff, who founded the Fecal Transplant Foundation, said no doctor in her home state of Indiana would administer treatment when she contracted the antibiotic-resistant strain in 2012. Too sick to travel, she and her husband took matters into their own hands.

After his stool was cleared as healthy, he mixed a sample with saline, put it in a blender and administered it by enema. Four hours later, Duff was able to get dressed and walk downstairs - something she hadn’t done for “months and months.”

“It’s a very simple procedure,” she said. “The major barriers to people doing it are finding the right donor and, I guess, what you call the ‘ick’ factor.”

‘EVERY DONOR IS DIFFERENT’

For now, FMT requires a stool sample to be screened, liquefied and delivered to the colon by nasal or rectal tube. Multiple studies have shown the technique to be largely successful in preventing relapses, following antibiotic therapy.

Patients must either find their own donor, as Duff did, or turn to a stool bank. According to the Fecal Transplant Foundation, fewer than 3 percent of the population qualify as a healthy donor.

“Every donor is different. Every center preparing fecal transplants is different,” said David Cook, head of research and development at Seres. “It doesn’t undergo the kind of rigorous checks for quality control that a modern pharmaceutical does.”

Partly to sidestep the “ick” factor, Seres and two other Massachusetts-based companies, Finch Therapeutics and Crestovo LLC, are developing a pill to deliver FMT - a solution that would eliminate the cost and risk of a colonoscopy.

Seres’ treatment missed its main goal in a mid-stage study but, after tweaking its original design, the company initiated a late-stage trial in June. Crestovo and Finch expect results next year from mid-stage trials of their oral treatments.

Finch Chief Executive Mark Smith said capsules would also be “easier to scale for patients.”

The potential market is large: half a million instances of C. diff infection are recorded every year in the United States, with 85,000 to 110,000 patients likely to experience a relapse, according to Seres.

Research firm GlobalData forecasts that the potential market size for C. diff treatments in seven key markets - the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Japan - will rise to almost $1.7 billion by 2026 from $630 million last year.

Smith said he expected new therapies to be priced competitively with existing C. diff antibiotics, such as Merck & Co’s Dificid.

From autism to obesity, the potential also exists for FMT to treat other conditions. Nearly 200 clinical trials of the treatment in various forms are under way.

“I don’t think anyone has it quite nailed yet,” said James Burgess, co-founder of non-profit stool bank OpenBiome. “But many of the hypotheses that are emerging seem reasonable.” (Reporting by Natalie Grover in Bengaluru; Additional reporting by Manas Mishra and Tamara Mathias; Editing by Robin Paxton)

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Foods Your Gut Hates
The Garlic and Onions You Always Cook With(01 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: They contain FODMAPs, or fermentable oligo-di-monosaccharides and polyols—carbohydrates that some people don't digest well in large amounts (garlic and onion are high in particular ones called fructans). While experts don't know for sure how many people have issues with FODMAPs, research suggests that people with irritable bowel syndrome (which affects 10 to 15 percent of Americans) are prime targets. Bacteria in our large intestine and colon start to ferment the FODMAPs, causing gas, bloating and cramping, says Neha Shah, MPH, RD, a clinical dietitian for Stanford Health Care.

How to fix it: If you can't imagine cooking without garlic and onions but your digestive tract is begging you to stop, try Shah's trick of simmering them in olive oil to infuse it with their flavors (the fructans don't leach out into the oil) and then cooking with the oil instead.

(credit:Kathrin Ziegler/Taxi/Getty Images)
Saturated Fat Bombs Like Ice Cream and Meat(02 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: The fat found in treats like ice cream and animal products like cheeseburgers can increase the growth of potentially harmful gut bacteria. When researchers put mice on a high-milk-fat diet for a study in Nature, it triggered overgrowths ofbilophila wadsworthia—a type of bacteria found in all of our stomachs but normally kept in check. The result? Severe inflammation in the colon. It's not because the bacteria are feeding on the milk fat, though—our bodies produce bile in order to digest certain fats, and "the bacteria is using that bile as a fuel source," says study author Suzanne Devkota, MD, a research fellow at Harvard's Joslin Diabetes Center. "It's like adding oxygen to a fire." Another study in Nature found that a high-saturated-fat diet in humans (bacon and eggs for breakfast, ribs and brisket for lunch, salami, prosciutto and cheese for dinner, plus pork rinds for snacks), led to increases in that same bile-loving bacteria.

How to fix it: Limiting your consumption of saturated fats can help keep this bacteria at normal levels. The American Heart Association recommends that healthy individuals get no more than 7 percent of their daily calories from saturated fat (roughly 16 grams of saturated fat on a 2,000-calorie-a-day diet), while people with high cholesterol should cap it at 5 to 6 percent of their daily calories (11 to 13 grams). Just in case you need another reason to adopt a more plant-based diet, consider that subjects on the meat-bonanza meal plan also reported less regularity in their bowel movements while following it.

(credit:Alex Jones)
The Sweet Treat in Your Morning Coffee(03 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: Artificial sweeteners contain FODMAPs, and that means they're osmotic, pulling water into your intestinal tract and potentially causing diarrhea. And because artificial sweeteners (look for ingredients that end in an "ol", like sorbitol or mannitol) are calorie-free, our bodies don't recognize them as nutrients and don't digest them, says Lisa Ganjhu, MD, a gastroenterologist at NYU Langone Medical Center. That leads to gas and bloating.

How to fix it: If you find that your stomach doesn't feel so great after you get your morning caffeine-and-fake-sugar fix, use small amounts of actual sugar instead.

(credit:Martin Dimitrov/E )
The Big-Batch Bean or Lentil Salads You Make for Lunch(04 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: FODMAPs are at it again—this time, it's the galactans in your legumes. If you think you may be sensitive to them (or any other FODMAPs on this list), bring it up with your doctor before altering your diet, as your digestive distress could actually be caused by a more serious underlying issue like celiac disease or inflammatory bowel disease, says Shah. If your doctor rules those out, ask about going on a FODMAP elimination diet, where all FODMAPs are removed for 6 weeks then slowly reintroduced to pinpoint which ones are causing your problems. You can find more information about FODMAPS and a low FODMAP diet here.

How to fix it: The galactans in beans and lentils can be at least partially removed by soaking them uncooked in water overnight then cooking them with a fresh batch of water, because the galactans get pulled out during the initial soak, says Shah. "My patients have far less gas and bloating when they prepare beans and lentils this way."

(credit:Elet1/iStock)
Your Choice of Cheese(05 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: Lactose falls in the FODMAP camp, so any cheese could pose problems for sensitive stomachs. But high lactose cheeses like cottage and ricotta are the most likely to cause digestive issues. These particular cheeses tend to undergo short straining processes, and less lactose gets removed as a result.

How to fix it: If you find that cottage and ricotta don't sit well with you, try snacking on low-lactose options like brie, feta and mozzarella. Hard cheeses like cheddar, parmesan and Swiss are also fair game, as they're low in lactose too. Just remember that when it comes to sensitivity to cheese (or any food that's high in FODMAPs), the amount that you're eating makes a difference, so try cutting back on your portion sizes before cutting out a food entirely.

(credit:Charlotte Franklin/Moment)
The Wine You Occasionally Wash Down Your Dinner With (and Then Some)(06 of06)
Open Image Modal

Why your gut's not a fan: True, it's not food, but alcohol can be bad for your gut too. Just one episode of binge drinking (for women, that means consuming 4 or 5 drinks within two hours) can cause bacteria to leak out of your gut into your bloodstream, found a 2014 study in PLOS One. The effect was more pronounced in women than in men, and it could lead to inflammation throughout the body. "It's not going to kill anyone immediately, but over time, this low-grade inflammation can predispose you to chronic diseases," says study author Gyongyi Szabo, MD, PhD, a professor of medicine at the University of Massachusetts Medical School.

How to fix it: Moderate drinking, meaning 1 drink per day for women, according to the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, is your best bet for avoiding the potential negative effects of alcohol.

(credit:Owen Franken/Photographers Choice)

HuffPost Shopping’s Best Finds

MORE IN LIFE