How The Fight For $15 Could Affect Your Kids

Child care workers say low pay undermines the quality of the care they provide.
|
Open Image Modal
Child care workers and children at Ubuntu Academy and Early Learning Center in Kansas City, Missouri, call for a $15 per hour minimum wage.
Child Care Fight For $15

It was a triumphant day for low-wage workers' Fight for $15 campaign. Hundreds of marches in cities across the country on Tuesday were rewarded with major, day-of policy announcements and even a question at the Republican presidential debate.

But what may have gotten missed within the ranks of a fast-food worker-dominated movement is a rising contingent of child care workers demanding dignity as well.

Dozens of child care workers and the families they serve joined other low-wage workers in Fight for $15 marches, arguing that the well-being of American children is at stake in their struggle for higher wages and union representation.

The caregivers and their supporters call their particular crusade the “Child Care Fight For $15.” In cities like Chicago, Detroit and Atlanta, they walked out of work to advocate for a union and a $15 per hour minimum wage. The entire workforce of at least six child care centers in Chicago participated in the protest, prompting four of those centers to close for the day, the SEIU-backed Fight for $15 reported.

The workers said their low pay and lack of benefits affect the children they supervise and instruct.

LiAnn Flakes, who cares for infants and toddlers in a Head Start-funded care center in Tampa, Florida, marched with fellow low-income workers to Tampa City Hall and other public institutions on Tuesday. After working as a child care provider for 22 years, she recently got a raise to $12.50 an hour. It's still not enough to make ends meet.

Flakes said a raise would make her a "more effective" caretaker and teacher. She'd have more money to spend on her ongoing professional training and supplies for her day care room -- expenses she already pays for using her own income.

"It is difficult," she said. "I believe in giving my job 110 percent."

Flakes' employer does not provide health insurance, and she can't afford to buy it on her own, so she goes without coverage. For a time, she bought coverage through a plan on the Affordable Care Act exchange, but found the monthly premiums too onerous. 

Since Flakes doesn't have insurance, her asthma often lands her in the emergency room, sidelining her from the job she loves.

“I spend a lot of time ill, because I am not able to get the medical care I need, because I cannot afford it,” she said. Flakes estimated that she owes $11,000 in outstanding hospital bills as a result.

All of the groups responsible for funding professional child care centers -- the federal government, state governments and the private sector -- can afford to pay child care workers $15 an hour, Flakes said.

“We’re doing what’s required of us,” she said. “They should do what is required of them.”

Open Image Modal
Child care workers and children join a Fight for $15 demonstration outside a fast-food establishment in Richmond, Virginia, on Tuesday.
Child Care Fight For $15

Child care workers are among the country’s lowest-paid workers, despite the fact that the cost of child care services is prohibitively expensive for the typical American family. The median wage for child care workers is nearly 40 percent below the median wage for workers in other fields, according to an analysis by the Economic Policy Institute that was released last Thursday.

As a result, the percentage of child care workers living below the federal poverty level is more than twice the percentage of those in other fields. According to EPI's report, 14.7 percent of child care workers live in poverty, versus 6.7 percent of other workers.

The majority of the child care workers who demonstrated on Tuesday are employed by care centers that rely on federal or state government funding, either directly or indirectly through payment assistance for low-income parents. 

In fact, because the state and federal governments provide the lion’s share of many of these child care centers' funding -- funding that helps to cover workers' salaries -- child care center owners are among the Child Care Fight For $15’s staunchest backers. Some owners joined their employees at demonstrations on Tuesday.

Edie Reichard, director of the state-funded Sleeping Giant Day Care in Hamden, Connecticut, spoke on a public panel sponsored by the Fight for $15 on Tuesday and testified to Connecticut’s newly established Low Wage Employer Board, a state government body designed to make recommendations to the legislature on challenges facing low-wage workers. She vehemently supports workers' demand for a $15 minimum wage. 

 

Connecticut provides Sleeping Giant Day Care with a grant of $8,000 per child, Reichard said. That allows her to pay her teachers $13-$14 an hour, and her teaching assistants $12 an hour. State funding per child would have to double to enable her to pay her employees at least $15 an hour, she estimated.

Meanwhile, there is a high turnover rate for teaching assistants at her care center because of the relatively low pay, Reichard said. Teaching assistants who have kids often miss work, since they can't afford child care for their own school-age children.

Reichard became active in the Fight for $15 after the Connecticut chapter of SEIU asked owners of publicly-funded child care centers to get involved, citing their shared interests.

Like SEIU, which is funding and organizing the Fight for $15, the care center owners want the state to increase payments to child care centers, which they say will allow centers to pay workers at least $15 an hour.

But Reichard’s alliance with the SEIU-backed campaign has its limits. While she supports workers’ demands for $15 an hour, she does not support their efforts to unionize, a key component of the Fight for $15’s demands. Her child care center couldn't afford to manage collective bargaining with a union, she said.

She stopped short of saying she would actively oppose a union-organizing drive if it were to gather steam.

“I am not really sure,” Reichard said. “I am kind of neutral on it.”

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story stated that Reichard was unable to participate in any Fight for $15 protests. In fact, she was unable to join a local strike line, but she participated in official events.

Also on HuffPost:

The Faces of the Fight for 15 Movement
(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Gabrielle Hatcher
Age: 27
City: New York
Job: Waitress
Pay: $5 per hour plus tips
Why she’s protesting: "As a tip worker, I make a sub-minimum wage of $5 an hour plus tips, so I never really know how much I’m going to make, and in every other position you generally know how much you’re making before you take a job. A lot of people here are wondering why we’re talking about racial justice, but racial justice and economic justice are really just two sides of the same coin here. As a woman of color, I’ve been passed up for promotions and higher-paying positions. I’ve been turned down from positions where I’d be making more money because they only hire white males at a lot of fine dining establishments in the city. I live with five other workers in the city and we struggle to make ends meet because we never know how much we’re going to work. We work for eight hours plus, and sometimes we only make 20 bucks. We can’t afford health coverage, so we stay sick longer, we serve the public when we’re healthy and if we don’t find coverage we risk losing our job. Being a tip worker kind of exploits you to the whims of total strangers. It’s kind of ridiculous that businesses expect their customers to pay their employees. It doesn’t make any sense, especially because I’ve experienced harassment a lot and there’s not a lot of room to speak up or defend yourself without losing your job."
(credit:Willa Frej/Huffington Post)
(02 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Jorel Ware
Age: 34
Employer: McDonald's
Pay: $8.75 per hour
Why he's protesting: "I’m a fast food worker. What’s motivating me is there’s a lot of different issues going on in the United States with living wages, with Black Lives Matter issues, immigration reform, childcare. These issues are basically the same because everybody’s going through them, black and brown people are going through this. This is how it comes together and it gives me the drive and I’m finally willing to make a change. I’ve worked at McDonald's for two and a half years."
(credit:Willa Frej/Huffington Post)
(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Berta Chacon
Age: 48
Employer: A beauty salon
Pay: $300 per week
Why she’s protesting: "We are fighting for $15 an hour in order to survive in this city that is very expensive. Our salaries are very low, so we need $15 in order to survive and to help our families in our home countries."
(credit:Willa Frej/Huffington Post)
(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Ernestina Sandoval (right)
Age: 35
City: Richmond, California
Employer: McDonald's
Pay: $9.60 per hour
Why she's protesting: "I'm here because they don't have our back. When we were robbed, the owner didn't really come see how the workers were. It was really sad. We're asking for security. This McDonald's is in a bad area. I depend on my McDonald's payment. I have a teenage daughter here and a son out of the country. I try to send money home but sometimes all I can afford is $20. I'm an everything, multitasker having to do six or seven jobs. I've always made minimum wage. I started at $8 an hour. Now I make $9.60."
(credit:Michael Mclaughlin/Huffington Post)
(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Warner Massey
Age: 55
City: Fort Washington, Maryland
Employer: Goodwill of Greater Washington, working in the U.S. Senate
Job: Custodial
Pay: $13.50 per hour
Why he’s protesting: "I’m no different than nobody else here. I need more money, too. That’s the bottom line. ... I figure if I have a couple more dollars on my check, that will help ease the pain a little bit. I haven’t been able to take my wife on a decent vacation. We’ve been married for nine years. That’s what my goal is. Make a little bit more money so I can do these things.”
(credit:Dave Jamieson/Huffington Post)
(06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Shardeja Woolridge
Age: 19
City: Hayward, California
Job: Cashier/student at Berkeley Community College
Employer: McDonald's
Why she's protesting: "I'm here for the fight for 15. We work very hard. I've seen wage theft by McDonald's. I haven't been paid for overtime. We're not allowed to use our sick days either. I called in one time and said, 'I'm not feeling well' and first, they put me on hold. Then they just hung up on me. We need security too. I've been attacked by a customer. She punched me in the face at the drive-through window. Then I got punished for trying to defend myself. The money is just not enough. I want to help my mom out, but I can't. I can't pay for books at school, either. Things need to change."
(credit:Michael Mclaughlin/Huffington Post)
(07 of07)
Open Image Modal
Name: Shariff El-Shariff
Age: 36
City: Washington, D.C.
Employer: Starbucks, Union Station, D.C.
Job: Shift supervisor
Pay: $14 per hour
Why he’s protesting: “We’re struggling. We need to raise our kids and raise our families. With the price of food and the price of rent, we don’t know what to do. I work with people who make $11 per hour. It’s not enough for them. We’ll struggle until we get what we need.”
(credit:Dave Jamieson/Huffington Post)

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost