So, What Will Win Best Picture?

We weigh the odds in the Oscars' biggest contest.
Open Image Modal
Fox Searchlight/Warner Bros/Open Road

The Oscar nominations are in, which means there's no time to waste in predicting who will take home little gold men at next month's awards. Per the Academy's regulations, campaigning is a far quieter endeavor once the ballot has been announced. That's not to say things can't shift dramatically between now and Feb. 28, but it does mean we have a semi-clear window into what might bulldoze the Best Picture race. Let's take a look at each of the eight nominees, presented in alphabetical order. (P.S. Fear not, “Carol,” we’re still mourning your egregious snub.)

"The Big Short"
Paramount
"The Big Short" collected all the requisite nominations to make it a front-runner: Adam McKay nabbed a direction nod anda screenplay nod (which he shares with Charles Randolph), Christian Bale made an appearance in Best Supporting Actor, and Best Film Editing gave the movie a fundamental boost among the tech kudos. In depicting the insiders who predicted the 2008 housing-bubble burst before it ravished the American economy, "The Big Short" has an urgency about it that could register with voters. But the other movie to amass acting, directing, screenplay andfilm-editing salutes was "Spotlight" -- and "Spotlight," which tackles sexual abuse within the Catholic Church, is riding a longer front-runner wave.
"Bridge of Spies"
Walt Disney Studios
The Academy consistently recognizes Steven Spielberg's work, but only one movie he's directed -- 1993's "Schindler's List" -- has garnered the top prize. The Cold War espionage drama "Bridge of Spies" seemed like an iffy player in the Oscar derby until the Producers Guild -- a reliable predictor of what will score Best Picture nominations -- included the movie among its annual awards. A Best Original Screenplay nod also helps, and there's a chance Mark Rylance could walk away with the Best Supporting Actor trophy. But the buzz surrounding the polished, traditionally crafted "Bridge" has been comparatively mute, and it's hard to imagine a majority of voters checking its box over the category's other choices.
"Brooklyn"
Fox Searchlight
Statistically speaking, it's hard to win Best Picture without a Best Film Editing nomination. Why? Because editing is essential to a movie's quality -- you're not supposed to notice the tricks that seamlessly unite multiple storylines and characters. "Birdman" stole the top prize last year without a film-editing nod, but that's an anomaly: Since the category was introduced in 1934, only 10 movies have won Best Picture without an editing designation. That doesn't bode well for "Brooklyn," whose only other categories are Best Actress (Saoirse Ronan) and Best Adapted Screenplay (Nick Hornby), making it 2016's Best Picture title with the fewest nominations.
"Mad Max: Fury Road"
Warner Bros.
With 10 nominations, "Mad Max" is second only to "The Revenant" as the year's most-honored film. That means its visibility is high, despite having opened way back in May. The problem is, outside of George Miller's deserved Best Director nod, the other eight are technical plaudits. Charlize Theron's Best Actress absence isn't a deal-breaker, as "Argo" and "Slumdog Millionaire" recently won Best Picture without any acting acknowledgements. More fatal is the lack of screenplay shout-out, as the last movie to win Best Picture without a screenwriting nod was 1997's "Titanic."
"The Martian"
20th Century Fox
"The Martian" scored the Golden Globe for Best Picture, but that doesn't mean much because a) the Hollywood Foreign Press Association has no voting overlap with the Academy and b) we can partly chalk it up to the movie sliding into the Globes' comedy categories, where it faced less competition. Still, "The Martian" is a great movie that concludes with the sort of grand sentimentality that registers with the Academy. Ridley Scott's Best Director snub hurts, but Ben Affleck's didn't prevent "Argo" from annexing the prize in 2013. The acting branch liked Matt Damon's performance enough to nominate him, and the writers appreciated Drew Goddard's script, which means "The Martian" may have enough voters championing it to slip ahead.
"The Revenant"
20th Century Fox
The last person to grab two consecutive Oscars for Best Director was Joseph L. Mankiewicz, for 1949's "A Letter to Three Wives" and 1950's "All About Eve." That makes it unlikely that Alejandro González Iñárritu, who won last year for "Birdman," will see dual victories. And since Best Director often goes to the guy (or Kathryn Bigelow) who helmed the year's Best Picture winner, that advances the statistical improbability that "The Revenant" will sweep. Furthermore, the movie was left off the Best Ensemble shortlist at the Screen Actors Guild Awards, and the actors branch -- which has a huge overlap with SAG's membership -- is the Academy's largest. And though its Golden Globe win provides a minor boost, "The Revenant" has another strike against it: no screenplay nomination. That's a lot of hindrances, and yet the inescapable campaign surrounding this movie's arduous arctic shoot -- Leo suffered for his art, people! -- seems to imply it still has momentum.
"Room"
A24
Lenny Abrahamson's unexpected inclusion in Best Director gives "Room" a momentum many didn't expect. In fact, some pundits on awards-handicapping bible GoldDerby removed it from their Best Picture predictions after the Producers Guild and Writers Guild awards left it off their shortlists. Despite Emma Donoghue's screenplay recognition and what could be a Best Actress victory for Brie Larson, its lack of technical nods doesn't bode well: The last movie to win Best Picture without making it into a single tech category was 1980's "Ordinary People."
"Spotlight"
Open Road Films
Declared the festival circuit's Best Picture front-runner back in September, "Spotlight" was never a question in this category. It could still prevail, even though it lost the Golden Globe and missed out on a couple of vital SAG nominations. There are a lot of grandiose movies to pick from ("The Revenant," "Mad Max," "The Martian," even "Bridge of Spies"), and if voters can't decide which feat of technical mastery to select, "Spotlight" offers an easy alternative. That's hardly the only reason it could win, though. Alongside "The Big Short," it's the only other movie to earn all four bellwethers in the Best Picture bullseye: Tom McCarthy is up for Best Director, it has two acting nominations (Mark Ruffalo and Rachel McAdams), McCarthy and Josh Singer's screenplay was recognized, and it boasts a coveted slot in Best Film Editing. Its triumph would mean voters can avoid consecutively awarding Alejandro González Iñárritu movies, and they can also, in a way, revisit the glory days of 1970s cinema, when the thematically similar "All the President's Men" competed for the same prize. Besides, voters might relish the chance to prioritize such an unfussy, effortlessly crafted film.

 
Also on HuffPost:

Best Movies of 2015
"Grandma"(01 of20)
Open Image Modal
No matter how sunny life is, it is never without frequent blips of sadness. Likewise, the most tactful comedies are singed with melancholy. Enter "Grandma," an amusing and wistful meditation on family and nostalgia. Lily Tomlin stars as a crusty, weed-smoking poet who helps her teenage granddaughter round up the funds for an abortion. Despite the progressiveness peppered throughout the film, "Grandma" is not a political screed. It's an examination of the history that has passed through a lifetime and the history that has yet to come. (credit:Sony Pictures Classics)
"Beasts of No Nation"(02 of20)
Open Image Modal
This searing portrait of West African warfare is a tough watch, largely because we see it unfold from the perspective of a child soldier. But that's what makes "Beasts of No Nation" powerful. Through bouts of violence emerge glimmers of hope, making the ecstasy worth the agony. "Beasts" took several gambles, too: It's Netflix's first original feature, and it puts first-time 15-year-old actor Abraham Attah at the film's vulnerable center. Both paid off, as did Idris Elba's commanding performance as a warlord whose strengths are swagger and ego. What writer/director/cinematographer Cary Fukunaga accomplishes in his brutal movie is, actually, anything but. You may leave "Beasts" feeling wrecked, but its intensity gives way to the utmost optimism. (credit:Netflix)
"Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck"(03 of20)
Open Image Modal
Music documentaries and biopics tend to feel rote, juxtaposing chanting crowds with childhood demons to symbolize the Power of Song, man. The title subject of "Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck" has well-documented demons, but director Brett Morgen uses his unprecedented access to the Nirvana frontman's archives to collate a narrative that feels as definitive as we could hope for. Incorporating animation, hand-written lyrics, diary entries and stunning home footage that informs Cobain's legacy without mythologizing him, "Montage of Heck" is an artful dissection of a modern icon. (credit:HBO)
"Chi-Raq"(04 of20)
Open Image Modal
When Spike Lee hollers, you listen. "Chi-Raq" demands your attention with an urgency that curdles amid the bloodletting gun violence splattered across any given day's headlines. Lee understands how current his film is, casting a modern-day Lysistrata in which women across Chicago's South Side deny their boyfriends sex until gang shootings end. With a red-hot lead performance from Teyonah Parris, "Chi-Raq" tackles race, gender and class with sizzling, messy audacity. (credit:Roadside Attractions)
"The End of the Tour"(05 of20)
Open Image Modal
Several of 2015's great independent films were just long conversations between a few characters. None was as soulful as "The End of the Tour," which chronicles the final days of David Foster Wallace's 1996 Infinite Jest book tour through the eyes of the Rolling Stone journalist profiling him. Jason Segel is a revelation as Wallace, all droopy gait and sheepish intellect. Jesse Eisenberg matches him note for note while Wallace and his doting but headstrong counterpart debate the value of art and fame in their quest to find common ground. Their interactions range from affectionate to fiery, examining the influence each of us has on the others around us. James Ponsoldt's film doesn't need to comment on every query it raises -- instead, it is content to postulate just as passionately as its characters. The upbeat, even romantic conclusion brings everything full-circle. (credit:A24)
"James White"(06 of20)
Open Image Modal
Plenty of movies focus on restless 20-somethings exploring their restlessness, but many lack import. Not "James White," in which first-time director Josh Mond keeps his camera trained closely on Christopher Abbott, as if we are peering into his mind. The angsty New Yorker he plays shares a care schedule for his fragile, cancer-stricken mother (an exceptional Cynthia Nixon) while navigating unemployment and aimlessness. As a love letter between a parent and her child, as well as a dissection of highs and steep lows, "James White" is compelling, unconventional and beautiful. (credit:Film Arcade)
"The Diary of a Teenage Girl"(07 of20)
Open Image Modal
"The Diary of a Teenage Girl" didn't find the theatrical life it deserved, which is a shame because the Sundance dramedy is refreshing and wise. In 1970s San Francisco, the title girl (Bel Powley) blossoms sexually and emotionally while the counterculture's afterglow weaves through everything in her path. "Diary" is based on Phoebe Gloeckner's graphic novel of the same name, and it shows: The movie bursts into clever, spontaneous illustrations, as narrated by the aspiring 15-year-old cartoonist at its center. Rarely is teenage sexuality depicted with such an honest and brazen edge, and Kristen Wiig, playing the protagonist's detached mother, gives her best performance to date. (credit:Sony Pictures Classics)
"45 Years"(08 of20)
Open Image Modal
One of the best moviegoing experiences is when a story stays with you for days, replaying in your head and adopting new layers of significance. "45 Years" is that movie. At first glance, it's almost painstakingly simple in execution. A married couple (Charlotte Rampling and Tom Courtenay) are preparing to celebrate their 45th anniversary when one receives notice that his ex's remains have been found years after her death. The information sends both for a tailspin as they realize that the marriage they've known for so long has, to a subjective degree, been tainted by this lost romance. "Weekend" director Andrew Haigh's film is relentlessly quiet, and all the better for it. We get little backstory about the couple, wisely leaving the audience to make interpretations and fill in gaps. Everyone who sees "45 Years" will come away with a different take on it, and on whether we ever truly know another person. (credit:Artificial Eye)
"Clouds of Sils Maria"(09 of20)
Open Image Modal
Anyone still dubious of Kristen Stewart's talent should see "Clouds of Sills Maria" pronto. It's a two-hander in which Stewart plays the astute assistant to a self-absorbed French movie star (Juliette Binoche) returning to the role that won her fame years ago. Much of Olivier Assayas' plush film is just the two characters deliberating about fame and growing older, making "Clouds" an elegant meditation on the way our lives intersect. Come for the Swiss Alps scenery, stay for a contemplative yarn that will percolate for quite some time. (credit:IFC Films)
"Spotlight"(10 of20)
Open Image Modal
For proof that pageantry isn't a prerequisite for stellar movies, look at "Spotlight." Its portrayal of the Boston Globe team that investigated allegations of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church is at once intricate and effortless. You won't find opulent performances or lavish aesthetics here; instead, Tom McCarthy directed and co-wrote an audit of moral corrosion that doesn't preach or proselytize. He also succeeded in getting a massive cast to feel like they'd lived in each of these roles for a lifetime, despite little backstory and few flourishes. (credit:Open Road Films)
"The Martian"(11 of20)
Open Image Modal
The problem with "Interstellar" was the science, and the problem with "Gravity" was the fiction. "The Martian" carries neither of those burdens. Ridley Scott's take on Andy Weir's popular debut novel is tightly paced, sharply written and wildly thrilling. Matt Damon, playing a skilled botanist stranded on Mars after his crew flees a dust storm, is sensational, but his winning performance is not without assists from an ensemble that includes Jessica Chastain, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Jeff Daniels, Mackenzie Davis and Michael Peña. Disco, potatoes and space probes have never been this fun or stirring. (credit:20th Century Fox)
"Ex Machina"(12 of20)
Open Image Modal
Alex Garland's directorial debut is the work of a burgeoning master. "Ex Machina" creeps up on you like a sunset, fading to dark so elegantly that you've hardly had time to process its significance. It stars a trio of actors who've appeared in multiple buzzy films this year: Domhnall Gleeson plays a programmer who wins a week-long stay at the home of a reclusive artificial-intelligence genius (Oscar Isaac) who's created a humanoid (Alicia Vikander) who may be too smart for her own good. The sleek thriller chugs along with an ominous hum, resulting in a killer third act that is both startling and profound. Also, Oscar Isaac disco-dances. (credit:A24)
"Tangerine"(13 of20)
Open Image Modal
No money to make your movie? No problem, said Sean Baker, who shot "Tangerine" on iPhones for a paltry $100,000. It sounds like a Sundance stunt, but the result is a firestorm. The kinetic comedy traces two transgender sex workers as they traverse Los Angeles on foot, seeking charm but often encountering sleaze and sorrow. With two confident first-time actresses at the core, "Tangerine" dares every queer depiction that follows it to be half as smart, open-minded and daring. (credit:Magnolia Pictures)
"Star Wars: The Force Awakens"(14 of20)
Open Image Modal
Year-end lists are fun to compile because films seen months ago have the chance to marinate. No such advantage for "Star Wars: The Force Awakens," however, which screened for press this week. Critics who waited to publish their rankings until after seeing it may look back in future years and regret its placement (or lack thereof). But for now, "The Force Awakens" remains an accomplishment. J.J. Abrams channels George Lucas' original trilogy while building a mythology that moves the franchise forward. Buoyed by a capable cast and a nostalgic script that hits many funny beats and services fans who've awaited the return of Han, Leia and Luke, "The Force Awakens" comes pretty damn close to being everything we need from a new "Star Wars" movie. (credit:Walt Disney Studios)
"Room"(15 of20)
Open Image Modal
Adapting any novel told from the perspective of a 5-year-old is a gamble, especially when half of the story takes place in a small garden shed. But Emma Donoghue makes it look like a picnic, and director Lenny Abrahamson gives this tale of a mother and her young son such poignancy. Kidnapped and held captive for several years, the pair's limited world opens up as the film progresses, and so does the audience's relationship to its own surroundings. Carried by stunning performances from Brie Larson and Jacob Tremblay, "Room" is that rare movie that makes you appreciate all the beauty we take for granted. (credit:A24)
"The Big Short"(16 of20)
Open Image Modal
It's the economy, stupid! But the way "The Big Short" presents it is anything but. In fact, who knew a nationwide financial crisis could be this fun? In the hands of Adam McKay, the story of the oddball insiders who predicted the 2008 housing-market collapse is a sleek, rollicking documentary disguised as a financial dramedy. Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling, Christian Bale, Brad Pitt and Melissa Leo headline an all-star cast that has the huge burden of making esoteric material relatable. With a sharp script and nimble pace, "The Big Short" rises to the occasion, charting greed with damning intrigue. Plus, where else can you see Selena Gomez pop up to explain economic metaphors? (credit:Paramount)
"Inside Out"(17 of20)
Open Image Modal
Pixar has spent two decades revising the world we inhabit, positing that life is more eclectic and imaginative than any of us assume. None of the studio's films has been as eye-opening as "Inside Out," which anthropomorphizes the five emotions that govern our 11-year-old protagonist. Joy, Sadness, Anger, Disgust and Fear shepherd her through her family's cross-country move, resulting in a profound parable that reminds us of what we should have known all along: There is no happiness without occasional despair. Thanks for taking us to the moon, "Inside Out." (credit:Walt Disney Studios)
"Brooklyn"(18 of20)
Open Image Modal
What happens when the place you call home no longer provides the life you need? Nick Hornby poses that question in his best script yet, adapted from Colm Tóibín's celebrated 2009 novel. Presented with understated beauty, "Brooklyn" is a tale of searching -- for identity, for companionship, for comfort -- after abandoning every familiarity you've known. Saoirse Ronan is the crux of that journey, playing an Irish emigrant who leaves her homeland behind for better professional prospects in New York. With grace, director John Crowley isolates "Brooklyn" from the surfeit of male-centric films about growing up. It's a triumph. (credit:Fox Searchlight)
"Mad Max: Fury Road"(19 of20)
Open Image Modal
In rebooting his sparse 1979 dystopian classic, George Miller revved new life into the "Mad Max" franchise, proving noise doesn't have to negate substance. Beneath the hyper-saturated hues of the movie's punk-rock badlands is a feminist paean propelled by Charlize Theron's battle-scarred Imperator Furiosa, one of the year's best characters not to receive top billing. Miller used practical effects instead of computer-generated wizardry to craft a thriller that's at once chaotic and clearheaded, proving that razing cities with a few keystrokes isn't necessary for an action flick to comment on our world's ecological and moral condition. (credit:Warner Bros.)
"Carol"(20 of20)
Open Image Modal
From its misty opening shots to a wordless finale brimming with hope, "Carol" is radiant. Todd Haynes walked us through the cloistered alleys of the 1950s' sexual politics in "Far From Heaven," but here he trades glossy melodrama for grainy restraint. Working with a breathless Phyllis Nagy script based on Patricia Highsmith's 1952 novel The Price of Salt, Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara are a class and generation apart, yet the vitality each character gives the other is immediate. Rarely is a love story committed to film without a trace of Hollywood schmaltz, but "Carol" strips its two leads -- and their supporting comrades, including the excellent Kyle Chandler and Sarah Paulson -- of the overwrought romanticism that's all but immutable on the big screen. "Carol" is perfect. (credit:The Weinstein Company)

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost