Postpartum Depression: Can You Have It More Than Once?

Here's what moms can do to better protect their mental health the next time around.
Open Image Modal
Getty Images
Mental health experts explain the risk of PPD returning after the second, third or fourth child and share their advice.

May is Maternal Mental Health Month, so HuffPost Parenting and Wellness are shining a light on postpartum well-being. From how new moms handle those early days as parents while struggling with their own mental health to how to be there for friends and family, we’ve created a space for moms and their loved ones to feel seen and heard in those first trying months of parenthood. See the full series here.

After Sara Ahmed’s first child was born in 2008, she was struggling emotionally. Sure, there were moments of joy during that first year, but she was also feeling lost, sad and hopeless. 

“Compounded with the most exhausting sleep schedule and fatigue that really, nothing can prepare you for of my life, it really made for an isolating and confusing time for me,” Ahmed, a writer who covers motherhood, mental health and other subjects on her blog Sugar Land Sara, told HuffPost. 

It took a year for Ahmed to realize that something wasn’t right with her. She finally made an appointment with a psychiatrist who diagnosed her with postpartum depression and started her on a low-dose antidepressant. 

“That and therapy made all the difference in the world,” Ahmed said. 

“Having an established relationship with a therapist felt like a security blanket because I knew if I started to drown, I wouldn’t be trying to find help in the midst of it all.”

- Sara Ahmed, mental health and motherhood writer

When she had her second child in 2013, Ahmed’s PPD did return — as it does for many moms — but this time, she felt much more prepared. She knew more about the condition, what causes it and how to manage it. She had already scheduled some appointments with a psychiatrist and a therapist during the first several months of her son’s life. And she was more open with loved ones about what she was going through. 

“Just knowing the upheaval my mind — and not just body — would go through postpartum really helped me set more reasonable expectations for life with a newborn again,” Ahmed said. “And honestly, having an established relationship with a therapist felt like a security blanket because I knew if I started to drown, I wouldn’t be trying to find help in the midst of it all.”

If you’ve been through postpartum depression before, you may worry about what this means for your future pregnancies. Below, experts explain the chances of it coming back and offer advice on how to prepare if it does. 

Women who have had PPD before are at greater risk of having it again. 

Postpartum depression is a mental health disorder that impacts 10 to 15% of mothers. Symptoms of PPD may include persistent feelings of sadness, irritability or worthlessness, trouble bonding with the baby, difficulty concentrating, loss of interest in activities or hobbies you once enjoyed and thoughts about harming yourself or your child, among others. These mood changes last longer than the “baby blues” that many women experience during the first couple weeks after giving birth. 

Having a history of postpartum depression does, indeed, put women at an increased risk of recurrence. Studies have indicated that anywhere from 25% to 50% of moms will develop PPD again after a subsequent pregnancy. 

Other factors that raise your risk of PPD, according to perinatal and reproductive psychiatrist Alison Reminick, include having prenatal depression or anxiety, a family history of depression or anxiety, dealing with a recent stressful life event (like the death of a loved one), a lack of social support, a poor relationship with your partner, child care stress and an infant with a difficult temperament. Having complications with pregnancy, birth or breastfeeding can also play a role. 

But that doesn’t mean PPD is a certainty. 

First-time moms often have no idea what to expect when it comes to childbirth and caring for a newborn. The unfamiliarity and uncertainty can be overwhelming and can lead to feelings of anxiety, helplessness and hopelessness. But by the time you have a second or third child, you have considerable experience under your belt — and that can make a big difference. 

“You know that you may not have the birth experience you desire, you know that breastfeeding might be difficult, you know the first three months are the hardest and that sleep is a luxury,” said Paige Bellenbaum, founding director of The Motherhood Center mental health clinic in New York City. 

“You have perspective,” she added. “This knowledge allows for mothers to be prepared in a different and better way.” 

Plus, you’re able to make more informed decisions about birth, infant care and self-care the second time around, all of which can have a positive effect on your mental and emotional well-being. 

Open Image Modal
SelectStock via Getty Images
Having some firsthand motherhood experience under your belt allows you to be prepared "in a different and better way," the next time, said Paige Bellenbaum, founding director of The Motherhood Center.

“You can choose to stay on your medication during pregnancy if your symptoms returned last time when you went off of it. You can decide that you want an epidural this time because your natural birth the first time felt traumatic physically and emotionally,” Bellenbaum said.

“You can decide to have a doula present during birth because last time you felt like nobody was taking you seriously or advocating for you during delivery. You know you can line up a postpartum doula or night nurse to help with night feeds so you can get more sleep or have your husband or another family member take some nights during the week.”

How moms can be better prepared the next time around: 

Mothers who have dealt with PPD before are more equipped to deal with the condition if it does happen again. You may not be able to prevent PPD entirely, but you can at least reduce the severity and length of your symptoms. 

Talk to a therapist while you’re pregnant — and preschedule some appointments for after the baby arrives.

Start building a relationship with a mental health professional during pregnancy so you have someone on speed dial during the postpartum period. They can help you address any symptoms before they reach an unmanageable level, said Reminick, the director of women’s reproductive mental health at the University of California, San Diego

A therapist can also connect you with a psychiatrist specializing in perinatal mental health who can prescribe medication if needed.  

“Certain medications have also been FDA approved and are successful in treatment of PMADs [perinatal mood and anxiety disorders], if needed, and many are compatible with breastfeeding,” Reminick said. “Meeting with a reproductive psychiatrist to assess for possible need for medication prior to or during pregnancy can also minimize risk.” 

Before the baby comes, have conversations with your partner or a close family member about what signs to look for.

What were some of your early symptoms the first time around? Discuss these — and others — with your loved ones ahead of time so you can all keep an eye out. If the signs weren’t apparent to you then or you’re having trouble remembering, ask someone close to you what they noticed at the time.

“Was it a loss of appetite? Was it not getting enough sleep? Was it feeling and acting irritable and easily frustrated? Create a checklist so that you can go through the symptoms in real time if they start to recur,” Bellenbaum said.

Lean on family, friends and caregivers for help.  

Moms often feel immense pressure to do it all themselves. But having a strong support system in place — and being willing to accepting their help — is essential. 

These people can provide a listening ear when you need to vent, check in to see how you’re doing, offer to pitch in with household chores like cooking and cleaning, watch your other children or help care for the baby. 

“Loved ones can help recruit and organize support — this can be family, friends, or a doula, nanny, or mother’s helper,” Reminick said. ”They should encourage daily outings like a walk or running an errand and allow healthy time away from the baby to engage in self-care. Allowing for a daily, uninterrupted four to five hour period where the mother can rest, relax or sleep can be very effective in staving off and alleviating PMADs.”

“The sooner you can get on top of your symptoms with treatment, the sooner you can feel better, return to your baseline and enjoy motherhood again.”

- Paige Bellenbaum, founding director of The Motherhood Center

Reminick also encourages her patients to think about what responsibilities can be outsourced during the postpartum period to allow more time for mom to connect with the baby and other loved ones. 

“Can meals be made in advance or can family and friends help with a meal train? Can the family use paper plates and cups so dishes do not have to be cleaned? Can they invest in a robot vacuum cleaner?” she said. 

And if you feel PPD coming back, don’t wait to get help.  

“The sooner you can get on top of your symptoms with treatment, the sooner you can feel better, return to your baseline and enjoy motherhood again,” Bellenbaum said.

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Books On Postpartum Mental Health Every New Parent Should Read
“The Fourth Trimester: A Postpartum Guide to Healing Your Body, Balancing Your Emotions, and Restoring Your Vitality” by Kimberly Ann Johnson(01 of11)
Open Image Modal
Kristen Russell, an inpatient primary therapist at Arizona-based mental health facility Sierra Tucson — which has a specialty in maternal mental health and postpartum depression — offered this book recommendation because of its holistic approach to the transition from giving birth to adjusting to worries over body and identity changes.

“The book highlights how precious this time is for women in today’s society and how the new mother can create a nurturing approach to unexpected emotions and struggles," she said. "[The author] highlights her own struggle with postpartum, as well as that of other women."

Buy the book for $14.
(credit:Amazon)
“This Isn’t What I Expected: Overcoming Postpartum Depression” by Karen Kleiman and Valerie Raskin(02 of11)
Open Image Modal
Russell also offered “This Isn’t What I Expected: Overcoming Postpartum Depression” because of the way it breaks down all the categories of postpartum moods and anxiety in an easy-to-digest format.

“The book explains the symptoms of each type of postpartum such as depression, anxiety/panic, obsessive-compulsive thoughts/urges and treatment options. And the book offers ways to cope with unexpected stressors after the birth of the baby,” she said.

Additionally, Ilyse Kennedy, a trauma therapist who specializes in perinatal mental health and complex trauma in Austin, Texas, said, “'This Isn’t What I Expected' acknowledges the grief and difficulties in experiencing postpartum depression."

"It is comforting in the ways it normalizes the experience for new parents to make them feel held in community with others who have endured similar experiences," she added.

Buy the book for $9.
(credit:Amazon)
“The Postpartum Husband: Practical Solutions for Living With Postpartum Depression” by Karen Kleiman(03 of11)
Open Image Modal
“The Postpartum Husband: Practical Solutions for Living With Postpartum Depression” comes highly recommended by psychologist Roseann Capanna-Hodge, who works with clients in Connecticut and New York.

“The partner or spouse of a woman with postpartum may not know what to do or how to support someone with postpartum. This book offers both information and practical guidance on how to give support to a postpartum woman,” she said.

Buy the book for $13.
(credit:Amazon)
“Good Moms Have Scary Thoughts: A Healing Guide to the Secret Fears of New Mothers” by Karen Kleiman(04 of11)
Open Image Modal
Lauren Gourley, a perinatal mental health therapist in Wisconsin, said she recommends “Good Moms Have Scary Thoughts: A Healing Guide to the Secret Fears of New Mothers” to almost every new parent she works with.

“It is both comprehensive and really easy to read in small moments between caring for the baby. It has beautiful illustrations and captures many of the stresses and challenges of postpartum depression along with providing tangible suggestions for how to cope and seek additional support,” she explained.

Buy the book for $15.
(credit:Amazon)
“Dropping the Baby and Other Scary Thoughts: Breaking the Cycle of Unwanted Thoughts in Motherhood” by Karen Kleinman, Amy Wenzel, Hilary Waller and Abby Adler Mandel(05 of11)
Open Image Modal
According to Sabrina Romanoff, a clinical psychologist at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City, "This book provides information, validation and clarification for the experiences of new mothers. It is written for clinicians but many patients have found the book to be helpful in its ability to explain why the negative thoughts are present and what can be done about them. It’s a hidden gem and one that many patients find incredibly valuable.”

Buy the book for $30.
(credit:Amazon)
“Beyond the Blues: Understanding and Treating Prenatal and Postpartum Depression & Anxiety” by Shoshana S. Bennett and Pec Indman(06 of11)
Open Image Modal
Hubbell recommended this book as a “practical guide that contains the most current pregnancy and postpartum resources for the prevention and treatment of postpartum depression and anxiety.”

She said “Beyond the Blues” also takes a deep dive into addressing postpartum anxiety, which sometimes occurs along with depression.

Buy the book for $13.
(credit:Amazon)
“The Pregnancy and Postpartum Anxiety Workbook: Practical Skills to Help You Overcome Anxiety, Worry, Panic Attacks, Obsessions and Compulsions” by Pamela S. Wiegartz(07 of11)
Open Image Modal
Nadkarni said obsessive-compulsive disorder affects 1 in every 5 women during or after pregnancy in the postpartum period, highlighting not only the importance of screening for OCD but also the utility of treating it. She said she often recommends “The Pregnancy and Postpartum Anxiety Workbook: Practical Skills to Help You Overcome Anxiety, Worry, Panic Attacks, Obsessions and Compulsions” to patients to help them get started with an approach to OCD.

Buy the book for $17.
(credit:Amazon)
“Breathe, Mama, Breathe: 5-Minute Mindfulness for Busy Moms” by Shonda Moralis(08 of11)
Open Image Modal
We know how important mindfulness is for our overall well-being, but new parents don’t always have the time to incorporate a long meditation session or other mindfulness activities. Fortunately, “Breathe, Mama, Breathe: 5-Minute Mindfulness for Busy Moms,” which was recommended by New York-based psychologist Emily Guarnotta, makes it easy.

“Mothers face many adjustments during the postpartum period that can be overwhelming. Mindfulness is an effective tool for helping [them] deal with these challenges and helps set them up for success in the future," she said. "You do not need to spend hours each day meditating in order to get the benefits. This book is an excellent resource for helping mothers learn and practice mindfulness skills in five minutes or less."

And despite the title, it’s not just for moms. “In this book there are 65 useful strategies to increase mindfulness amidst the daily activities of a parent, and can be used for both new fathers and mothers,” added Brian Wind, a clinical psychologist and adjunct professor at Vanderbilt University.

Buy the book for $12.
(credit:Amazon)
“Strong as a Mother: How to Stay Healthy, Happy, and (Most Importantly) Sane From Pregnancy to Parenthood” by Kate Rope(09 of11)
Open Image Modal
Ibinye Osibodu-Onyali, a licensed marriage and family therapist at The Zinnia Practice in California, recommended this book for its “somewhat humorous look at pregnancy and the postpartum period.”

Osibodu-Onyali said the author covers “common topics that new moms worry about such as difficulty breastfeeding, scary thoughts, how to seek support, how to inform family members if you’re struggling with postpartum depression, and even returning to work.”

Buy the book for $13.
(credit:Amazon)
“The Reluctant Father” by Phillip Toledano(10 of11)
Open Image Modal
Hubbell said this is a funny take on the “ambivalence many fathers feel toward their infant in the beginning. It can be a comforting read to know you are not alone and that postpartum hits dads too.”

Buy the book for $10.
(credit:Amazon)
“The Mother-to-Mother Postpartum Depression Support Book” by Sandra Poulin(11 of11)
Open Image Modal
When you are sleep-deprived, an overly clinical book is likely to get shelved; this is not that book, according to Hubbell. “The Mother-to-Mother Postpartum Depression Support Book” details the stories of real women who have experienced a variety of postpartum experiences and how they got through them.

Buy the book for $13.
(credit:Amazon)

HuffPost Shopping’s Best Finds

MORE IN LIFE